When it comes to selecting resources for parts manufacturing, two characteristics stand out above the others. These characteristics are the material’s hardness and mass. Strong and durable materials are becoming increasingly popular in different industries as a result of this. As a result, titanium vs aluminum comparison is necessary.
In today’s economy, every business is looking for new ways to deliver goods to market quickly. It allows them to select the suitable metal while maximizing profit. As a result, it became critical to think about materials that can reduce overall energy use. These metals have different uses due to their properties. You can use these metals in different industries and purposes.
To make the best decision, you must first learn about the different qualities of these materials. What are the similarities between aluminum and titanium? Which one must you go with for your parts? You will find the answers to all these questions in the following section.
Table of Contents
Comparison of Aluminum and Titanium on Different Aspects
Because these metals have excellent resistance and low mass, other factors must be considered when determining which alloy to employ for the parts.
Titanium is the solution to choose in circumstances where each gram matters. That is why titanium healthcare goods, specialized satellite elements, fittings, or brackets all work. Cost.
Aluminum will be the best metal for manufacturing or 3D printing because of its low cost. Although titanium is more expensive, it can provide value. Parts that are lighter in mass-save fuel in-vehicle applications and titanium elements last longer.
Another thing to consider is that soldering titanium is a tough procedure that needs a high level of experience. Aluminum is simple to deal with. It is affordable and cost-effective in many uses.
Aluminum assist uses that need better thermal conductivity, like a heating element. Titanium’s melting point is great for high-temperature uses, like aerospace engine parts, where ultimate strength is needed.
The solid material of the alloy and the liquid form of the metal is in balance at this level. The material may be easily manufactured or used for heating once it achieves that temperature.
Resistance to Corrosion
Another feature that can be utilized to make comparisons between titanium versus aluminum is corrosion resistance. Titanium and aluminum are both rust-resistant metals. However, one is better than the other, making it the better choice. Corrosion plays an important role in determining the properties of the metals.
Titanium is a corrosion-resistant metal because it is neutral. Titanium is the most compatible metal and has many applications in the medical field due to its inertness. You can use it in surgical instruments, and Ti 6-4 alloys stand up effectively in a saline environment, making them perfect for use in the marine sector. Aluminum alloys generate an oxide coating that prevents the material from reacting with corrosive attacks. However, atmospheric variables like heat, airborne pollutants, and chemical properties now influence the corrosion of these alloys.
Electrical conductivity is an object’s capability to let electricity to move because of a change in potential. Scientists use copper as a reference to find the electrical conductivity of other metals. Copper can be used to tell the electrical conductivity of aluminum and titanium.
When the resistivity of titanium was compared to that of copper, it showed that titanium has around 3.1 percent of copper’s conduction. As a result, it is a strong conductor of energy and can’t be used in applications where transmission is critical. Titanium is a great resistor despite not being a good conductor. Aluminum has a conductivity of 64% that of copper. It means that aluminum is preferable over titanium in situations where conductivity is critical.
Titanium is the most compatible material due to its resistance to corrosion and low reactivity, making it suitable for the medical sector like surgical equipment. Ti 6-4 is resistant to salt and is often used in maritime applications.
Brief Introduction for Aluminum Applications
Aluminum is the often used material on the earth. When exposed to oxygen, a small layer of aluminum oxide grows on it, making it almost corrosion-free, and its lightness prevents the parts from functioning as a boat anchor. Although aluminum does not deteriorate in acidic situations, it does erode in alkaline conditions.
It is being used in an ever-increasing variety of applications by combining its beneficial features like strength, mass, resistance, renewability, and formability. Aluminum is available to manufacture foil and construction products due to its properties.
The advantages of employing aluminum are closely related to its qualities. The following are some of these characteristics:
Resistance to Corrosion
A reactive oxide layer forms nearly instantly whenever the exterior of aluminum is introduced to the air. The oxide coating is corrosion resistant, and metal treatments like anodizing can improve it even further.
It is the best heat and power conductor. The main benefit of aluminum is that its conductivity is roughly double that of copper when measured by weight. As a result, aluminum is the most prevalent metal used in transmission lines.
Aluminum compositions in the 1000 or 6000 class are the best replacements for copper. These are suitable for all types of electrical conduction, even household wiring.
Aluminum, instead of copper, is used for a substantial amount of overhead higher voltage lines due to weight reasons. However, because of their poor strength, every strand should be strengthened by galvanized or aluminum-coated high-tensile metal wire.
It is a reflector of heat, making it the best choice for light fixtures, thermal rescue cloths, and structural insulation.
Aluminum is non-toxic and does not emit smells or taint the things it comes into contact with. As a result, the aluminum wrapper is acceptable for use in packing for products like food and pharmaceuticals.
Aluminum’s reusability is unrivaled. If recycled aluminum is contrasted to pure aluminum, there is no decrease in characteristics. Moreover, recycling aluminum necessitates about 5% of the power input needed to manufacture aluminum metal.
Aluminum is employed in sectors like transportation, preparing meals, power production, manufacturing, construction, and electric transmission due to the characteristics of different aluminum alloys.
Aluminum is used to substitute other metals like iron, titanium, and composites, based on the purpose.
Brief Introduction for Titanium Applications
Titanium alloys have high tensile power, have excellent corrosion resistance, and survive hot conditions. They are mostly employed in airplanes, power station pipes, armor plates, navy ships, rockets, and missiles due to these qualities. Below are mentioned some of the applications of titanium:
Applications for the public and architects
Titanium alloy is utilized in the automobile sector, particularly in car and motorcycle races, where low weight is critical while preserving high rigidity. Tennis rackets, cricket, and helmet grills are all made of titanium.
Applications in Medicine
It is used in the medical sector, including surgical instruments and implants, like hip balls that can last years since it is compatible (non-toxic and not refused by the system).
Titanium’s natural ability to osseointegrate allows it to be used in implant placement that can last up to 30 years. This characteristic is beneficial in the case of orthopedic implants. Titanium is utilized in image-guided surgical tools and scooters, crutches, or other devices requiring resistance and low mass.
The most appealing quality of titanium is its weight-to-strength proportion. This material is as durable as steel but is 45 percent lighter; nevertheless, it is 60 percent heavier than aluminum despite being twice as effective.
This proportion is what makes it perfect for aviation and other uses, but it also has several other characteristics that make it a valuable resource.
Titanium materials have tensile strengths ranging from 20,000 – 200,000 psi, however, most commercially available titanium has a tensile stress of roughly 63,000 psi.
The fatigue strength of titanium can be high. The finish can affect the strength, which is why pressure concentrators should be avoided.
Titanium has a smaller thermal expansion than copper and aluminum. Temperature changes will have a little effect on the size.
It is a poor electrical conductor. In contrast, titanium’s conductivity will be roughly 3 percent provided copper has 100% conduction.
An inert protective oxide develops on the metal’s surface, providing resistance to most natural acids. Titanium is an alternative for a durable, lighter weight if cost isn’t an issue.
Cost-effective aluminum is emerging as the best choice, thanks to advancements in coating processes and newly developed alloys. Today, many sectors are seeking new ways to increase profits. These revolutionary methods are projected to minimize production costs, reduce product mass, and decrease power usage. These elements could be used to distinguish the two elements from one another. Manufacturers are using aluminum and titanium in different sectors to manufacture goods.
Whenever you imagine a perfect combination of material attributes for products in the manufacturing industry, durability, and lightness jump to mind. In this situation, titanium vs aluminum is the first material that designers think of. Surprisingly, titanium vs. aluminum checks off other crucial boxes, like high heat resistance or corrosion resistance. Moreover, there is a wide range of factors that can be considered when deciding on a product for a specific application.